Iva Zanicchi: her role as a judge between successes and failures

Iva Zanicchi: a controversial judge

Iva Zanicchi, an icon of Italian music and a famous presenter, has served as a judge on several television programs from 2023 to today. Despite her undoubted talent, her contribution as a judge has often been considered banal, with votes that tended to be excessively generous. In an interview with Corriere della Sera, Zanicchi admitted her difficulty in judging, stating: “I don't know how to be a judge.

I’m terrible.” This self-analysis raised questions about her role and her ability to make critical judgments.

The dilemma of high grades

The singer explained the reason for her very high ratings, declaring: “I give 10 to everyone because I feel sorry for them”. This statement highlights an interesting aspect of her approach: the difficulty of judging objectively, especially when it comes to younger or more vulnerable contestants. Zanicchi stressed that giving a low rating to a child or an elderly person seems inappropriate to her, which leads her to always give a positive rating. However, this behavior has attracted criticism, as many viewers expect a more balanced and fair judgment.

Experiences in reality shows

In addition to “Io Canto Generation”, Zanicchi has participated in various reality shows, including “La Fattoria” and “L'Isola dei Famosi”. On these occasions, her role as a judge has often been questioned. In particular, her experience on “L'Isola dei Famosi” was considered a flop, so much so that she stated that she was not sorry for not having been reconfirmed as a commentator. “It's not my role even if I have fun”, she stated, highlighting her preference for other types of television commitments. Her replacement with Nicola Savino and Vladimir Luxuria was welcomed positively by her, who praised the skills of the new commentators.

Iva Zanicchi's future on television

Despite the criticism and difficulties in the role of judge, Iva Zanicchi continues to be a prominent figure in the Italian television scene. Her musical career and charismatic personality guarantee her a prominent place, even if her future in reality shows could be questioned. With her admission that she does not feel comfortable in the role of judge, it is legitimate to wonder what her next steps in the world of television will be. Her sincerity and her direct approach could prove to be an advantage, allowing her to explore new opportunities away from judgments and competitions.