The Court of Cassation has finalized the life sentence for Giampaolo Amato , 66, a former Virtus football team doctor and a renowned ophthalmologist from Bologna. The panel of judges from the First Criminal Section upheld the Prosecutor General 's Office's request and rejected the defense's appeal. Amato is charged with the murder of his wife Isabella Linsalata and his mother-in-law Giulia Tateo , who, according to the prosecution, were killed with a mixture of drugs, including sevoflurane and midazolam.
The trial reached its final hearing on November 19. Up to this point, the lower courts have held that the former doctor, an employee of the Bologna Local Health Authority , secretly administered the substances to the two women, three weeks apart . The victims died in October 2021.
The motive according to the judges of merit
In its 331-page judgment, the Bologna Court of Appeal described a double crime "driven exclusively by selfish motivations." According to the magistrates, Amato acted for two reasons: an extramarital affair, already known to his family, and the desire to take possession of the family home and medical practice , located in a building in the Murri district , one of the most elegant in Bologna.
The defense, represented by Professor Franco Coppi and attorney Valerio Spigarelli , has always maintained the defendant's innocence. Amato had, moreover, renounced all claims to the assets even before his arrest by the Carabinieri in April 2023 , about a year and a half after the deaths. The appeal to the Supreme Court requested a forensic medical assessment , which, according to the defense, had never been ordered in the previous proceedings.
Evidence collected during the investigation
The autopsy revealed the presence of benzodiazepines and anesthetic drugs in the bodies of the two women . The same substances were found in a bottle of wine kept by Isabella Linsalata's sister, Anna Maria Linsalata , who handed it over to investigators. The woman had noticed that Isabella, in the preceding months, had often appeared confused and dazed.
Another element concerns the movements recorded by the defendant's smartwatch , which place Amato in locations consistent with the time of his deaths. The prosecution , represented by prosecutor Morena Plazzi , described the case as "a horrible story of decent people." During the appeals trial, the Court affirmed the defendant's "criminal responsibility beyond any reasonable doubt."
The Supreme Court of Cassation deemed the appeal ruling an "unassailable decision" because it "extensively addresses all aspects." According to the Prosecutor General, the double homicide was planned with the intention of eliminating anyone who posed an obstacle to the defendant's future. The civil parties, Isabella's sister and Giulia Tateo's brother, also supported the prosecution's requests.
The position of the family members
Amato has always maintained his innocence. The couple's children also maintain his innocence and have repeatedly publicly expressed doubts about the judges' reconstruction of the case. One of the daughters stated: "The motive doesn't stand up to logic." She recalled that it was their father, along with his brother, who first requested an autopsy to clarify any suspicions related to genetic disorders.
The daughter herself questions why a man who was already publicly engaging in an extramarital affair would harm his wife. The family has announced that they will continue their fight: "We will continue to fight." With the Supreme Court's ruling, the life sentence becomes final and the case is now legally closed.
