In recent days, the behavior of Guillermo Mariotto , a judge on Dancing with the Stars , has been the center of heated debate. The Rai Uno program has seen mounting criticism from hosts, commentators, journalists, and many social media users, who deem the actions of Barbara d'Urso last Saturday intolerable.
Now the voice of Giuliano Peparini , theatre director and choreographer known for his work on Amici , has also been added , who condemned the words and gestures of the juror.
The perfume on Barbara d'Urso and the comments on the stench
The point that has caused the most discussion concerns the spray of perfume on Barbara d'Urso , accompanied by comments about the alleged stench.
Peparini stated that he was disappointed to see what happened in the last episode of the show. He finds it inconceivable that a jury member would insult the contestants, make fun of others, and make inappropriate comments about colleagues and participants. The choreographer emphasized that those sitting at a judging table should base their judgments on real dance expertise , not on a lack of confidence, which, in his opinion, is lacking in this preparation.
She called his words "deeply bitter," referring to the atmosphere that was created in the studio.
Peparini particularly criticized Mariotto's way of addressing others. According to the choreographer, the juror has no restraint in his speech, and this is particularly serious given that the program airs on a public network, in front of families and minors. He added that the responsibility of a television judge also includes language and respect for others, especially on a program that reaches everyone's homes.
Carolyn Smith and the case of Giovanni Pernice
In his speech, the choreographer also referred to Carolyn Smith , the only member of the jury with recognized technical expertise in dance. Peparini wondered how unpleasant it would be for her to sit next to vulgar comments, and argued that a professional of this caliber deserves a discussion commensurate with her expertise, or at least free of vulgarity.
Peparini then recalled an incident that occurred last month , when Mariotto told Giovanni Pernice he was rude and should shut up. For a choreographer, competence should be the basis of any evaluation, while a lack of technical knowledge does not justify resorting to vulgarity, nor asking a teacher to remain silent when expressing an opinion or attempting to respond.
Noemi Bocchi's split and the joke about Francesco Totti
Peparini also expressed disgust at what happened after Noemi Bocchi 's performance during the October 24 episode . The contestant had just performed a split when Mariotto said to her: "I saw your split in the air and I understood, Francesco Totti, the reason why..." For the choreographer, such a phrase transforms a dance gesture into a gratuitous allusion, which adds nothing to the show, the competition, the audience, or television.
Noemi Bocchi also distanced herself from the joke, calling it unfortunate. In her statement, she explained that she's willing to accept criticism, which she considers useful for growth, but clarified that such off-color references to her private life didn't please her and had nothing to do with the challenge she was facing.
Mariotto's reply: Noemi is like the Moon
Even on this occasion, Mariotto didn't apologize with conviction, as he had done in the case of Barbara d'Urso and the perfume affair. A guest of Caterina Balivo on La Volta Buona , the judge compared Bocchi to the moon , because she doesn't shine with her own light but with reflected light. With this image, he explained, he wanted to praise her skill in holds and acrobatics, qualities that could lead her to the final.
These are her words on the show: "I don't apologize. Noemi is not a star, but a moon: a natural satellite that revolves around the Earth, not powered by its own light but by reflected light. Acrobatics are her forte, and those are the key to her reaching the final. I wanted to say this, but they wouldn't let me. And then, if you find a partner to do acrobatics with, it's wonderful."
The judge's outbursts continue to provoke strong reactions, and the number of those who consider his excesses during episodes of Dancing with the Stars to be excessive is growing.
