> > Forensic geneticist: "'Cold cases'? Solutions possible thanks to advances in...

Forensic geneticist: "'Cold cases'? Solutions are possible thanks to scientific advances, but DNA isn't magic."

Forensic geneticist: "'Cold cases'? Solutions are possible thanks to scientific advances, but DNA isn't magic."

(Adnkronos) - Continued advances in genetic research undoubtedly offer the opportunity to delve deeper into unsolved crimes and open up new avenues for investigation. "It's possible to revisit cold cases and, at times, even find solutions, but DNA isn't a magic wand. And there...

(Adnkronos) – Continued advances in genetic research undoubtedly offer the opportunity to delve deeper into unsolved crimes and open up new avenues for investigation. It's possible to revisit cold cases and, at times, even find solutions, but DNA isn't a magic wand. And there are significant technical limitations to consider for older cases.

Limitations related to the collection and preservation of samples taken from crime scenes at a time when their value was not even known." This was explained to Adnkronos Salute by Paolo Fattorini, president of Ge.fi, Italian Forensic Geneticists, a group associated with Simla, the Italian Society of Forensic Medicine, at a time when DNA is once again being used to provide answers in several cases, such as the Monster of Florence case.

 

"Until the early 90s," explains Fattorini, "the technical possibility of conducting genetic testing in crime cases was unheard of. But over the last thirty-five years, there has been a dramatic evolution in technology, so what was once unthinkable can now be done in a couple of days of laboratory work."

This is an incontrovertible fact. But working on 'ancient' artifacts, in the sense of 30 or 50 years ago, presents significant challenges. The number one problem is linked to the fact that at the time, since DNA analysis didn't exist, no one bothered to treat the artifacts in the most appropriate way. If you look, for example, at photos of news cases from forty-five years ago, you'll see that the operators were all without overalls, masks, or gloves. At the time, the crime scene was completely contaminated. This is also a fact. So when analyzing artifacts from that era, you must first consider the real possibility of contamination by people who had nothing to do with the crime. Personally, I remember that in a news case from thirty years ago, we found a cigar at the crime scene and then discovered that it had been left there by the deputy prosecutor who had inspected the scene. Unfortunately, that's how we worked. And that has to be taken into account.  

At the time—and this is the second problem—"since these technologies didn't exist, the finds were preserved without the necessary care: placed in boxes, in nylon bags. And then perhaps stored in some damp basement, in unsuitable conditions. It must therefore be considered that the finds contain DNA that is sometimes very degraded and doesn't actually provide any kind of result. These are the two major critical issues." In short, for unsolved cases, "many things can be done, but we must take into account the limitations: DNA analysis isn't part of the world of magic, it's something scientific. And like all scientific questions, it has its limits," concludes Fattorini.  

News

webinfo@adnkronos.com (Web Info)

Continue on the app The news of your city, in real time.
Open in app App Store