The Court of Cassation puts a final end to Mario's case Roggero, the jeweler of Grinzane Cavour condemned for killing two robbers and wounding a third during a robbery in 2021. In motivations of the sentence, filed on November 17, the judges exclude self-defense and reconstruct the reasons why the man would have acted with a «deliberate assault», moved by «intention to take justice into one's own hands».
Mario Roggero, from the 2021 robbery to the final sentence of 14 years and 9 months
The incident dates back to April 28, 2021 , when three men entered Roggero 's jewelry store in Gallo di Grinzane, threatening the retailer and his family with a toy gun and a knife. After stealing several valuables, the robbers left the store.
The jeweler approached them armed with a .38 caliber pistol and opened fire: Giuseppe Mazzarino and Andrea Spinelli were killed, while Alessandro Modica was wounded. After always maintaining that he had acted to defend his family, Roggero was sentenced to 17 years by the Assize Court of Asti on December 4, 2023. On December 3, 2025, the Turin Court of Appeal reduced the sentence to 14 years and 9 months.
On July 15, 2026, the Supreme Court of Cassation rejected the defense's appeal, making the conviction final. The jeweler, now 72, is serving his sentence in Bollate prison.
Roggero's conviction, the reasons behind the sentence clarify: "Deliberate assault."
Mario Roggero acted with a conscious choice, without being driven by the need to protect himself or his family. This is the conclusion reached by the First Criminal Section of the Court of Cassation, in the reasons filed today, Tuesday 17 November, relating to the ruling of July 15, 2026 which made the conviction of the jeweler from Grinzane Cavour, in the province of Cuneo, definitive.
As reported by Rai News, in the 34 pages the supreme judges reconstruct the man's conduct, confirming the penalty di 14 years and 9 months of imprisonment for the killing of two robbers and the wounding of a third, during the events that occurred on April 28, 2021. According to the Court, it was not a reaction dictated by a mistaken perception of danger or excessive caution, but a voluntary decision. «No mere imprudence or inexperience in the calculation of the danger and the means of salvation was found in the action» of Roggero, the judges write, underlining that the businessman acted with a «voluntary and conscious choice», giving life to a «deliberate aggression not justified by the need for defense».
The decisive factor concerns the moment the shots were fired : the three men had already left the jewelry store and were reaching the car they used to escape with the stolen goods. Roggero chased them outside, firing when, according to the Supreme Court's reconstruction, the risk to the safety of those inside the store had already passed.
Homicide and the intention to take justice into his own hands: what the judges wrote about Roggero
The Supreme Court has excluding also the possibility of recognizing a putative self-defense, rejecting the argument that the jeweler might have feared the robbers would return to the shop. For the magistrates it was a purely hypothetical scenario, devoid of concrete elementsThe criminals had already taken the valuables and were near the car they intended to drive away in. In interviews, the jeweler described his initiative as the only way to stop the perpetrators and bring them to justice. This attitude, according to the judges, confirms his "intention to take justice into one's own hands».
The Court of Cassation also reaffirmed the malicious nature of the murders: from the ballistic reconstructions it emerged that Roggero he fired several shots in quick succession, at human height and at a short distance, directing them towards the robbers. A method which, according to the sentence, demonstrates the conscious acceptance of the possibility of causing death of the people affected and prevents the facts from being reclassified as manslaughter or unintentional homicide.
