The Senate approved an amendment by the Brothers of Italy party to the School Decree requiring publishers to sell digital versions of textbooks at a discount of at least 50% compared to the paper version. The vote on Thursday, November 19, was 84 in favor, 76 against, and one abstention.
The provision is not yet law : the decree must be examined by the Chamber.
The measure addresses the problem of high book prices , the annual expense that weighs on the budgets of families with children in middle and high school. However, the measure divides the majority, with Forza Italia opposed, and is met with opposition from publishers and booksellers.
What does the amendment provide and when would it come into force?
The bill, signed by Senators Ella Bucalo and Anna Maria Fallucchi , establishes that publishers must offer an electronic version of the textbooks listed in school and university curricula at a discount of at least half the price. The file can be downloaded on up to three devices, is copy-protected, and cannot be transferred to third parties.
Those who purchase it can print up to 15% of the pages, at their own expense and for personal use. The interactive content will remain accessible for three school years from purchase.
There is also a restriction for schools: a book without a digital version at a reduced price cannot be adopted, both for titles already on sale and for new ones. The choice of textbooks remains with the teaching staff, and those who prefer paperbacks can continue to purchase them.
The discount will not go into effect immediately. The rules will apply from the school or academic year following the one in which the law converting the decree becomes effective. If the Chamber of Deputies approves the text, the first year affected will be 2027/2028.
How much do you really save?
The basic calculation is simple: the savings correspond to the paper price multiplied by 50%. According to the average costs for 2026/27 indicated in the decree's technical report, the textbook for the first year of middle school costs €298,19, and the discounted digital version would drop to €149,10. For the first year of high school, the cost would go from €317,19 to approximately €158,60, while for the eighth year of high school, it would go from €293,75 to €146,88.
For a family with two children, one in the sixth grade and one in the sixth grade, the theoretical savings is around €307. For the entire cycle, the Italian Competition Authority estimates an average expenditure of €580 for middle school students and €1.250 for high school students. Applying the discount to these values, the savings would be approximately €290 for middle school students and €625 for high school students. The Brothers of Italy party estimates a savings of up to €200 per year per child, a figure that exceeds the estimates derived from the average expenditure.
However, this is a theoretical limit . The calculation assumes that all manuals are available in digital format, that the starting price is the same as the paper version, and that there are no additional costs. Devices, prints, and supplementary materials are excluded, while the regulation provides only a minimal discount and no direct contribution to families.
Publishers, booksellers and still open issues
The Italian Publishers Association considers the measure unnecessary and harmful. According to the association, the mandatory discount could curb investment in a new book market worth approximately €800 million annually, and the sector was apparently not consulted. Confcommercio , with its booksellers' constituency, has also called for the rule to be repealed and is proposing a 19% deduction on book purchases as an alternative.
The second-hand market, worth approximately €150 million annually, poses another problem. A second-hand book can cost less than a discounted ebook, and those who use loan or school loans derive less benefit, because the files are non-transferable and digital licenses have transferability restrictions. The Authority also reports that over 95% of classrooms use paper books with a digital component, but only 16% of digital licenses are active.
For the devices, Federconsumatori estimates a cost of over €421 per student. With an average saving of about €150 per year, recovery would take almost three years, assuming the tablet doesn't need to be replaced sooner. The bill could still change in the Chamber of Deputies, and the actual savings will depend on how many books schools actually choose in digital format.
