The Court of Cassation has finalized the 14-year and 9-month sentence for Mario Roggero , a jeweler from Grinzane Cavour, in the province of Cuneo. He was accused of killing two robbers and wounding a third during the robbery of his shop on the 28th . The decision was made with the ruling of July 15th , handed down by the First Criminal Section.
The judges' reasons for self-defense
In their reasons, the judges ruled out any evidence of recklessness or incompetence in managing the danger. According to the Court , Roggero acted voluntarily and consciously, placing his actions within a deliberate attack not justified by the need to defend himself. The statements made by the defendant after the events, in which he spoke of a single way to stop the robbers, were considered evidence of his intention to take justice into his own hands.
The appeal process and the end of the assault
At first instance, the sentence was 17 years for double murder and attempted murder. On appeal, it was reduced to 14 years and 9 months . According to the Court of Appeal, the robbery had already concluded when the shots were fired: the robbers had left the shop and were getting into their car, so neither the jeweler nor his family were exposed to any real danger.
For this reason, self-defense has not been recognized, because it requires an ongoing attack or present danger.
During the robbery, 58-year-old Giuseppe Mazzarino and 44-year-old Andrea Spinelli died . A third man, Alessandro Modica , managed to escape despite his injuries. The victims' families were awarded a provisional executive order of €780, plus legal fees.
The Compensation Bill and Political Reactions
The Council of Ministers has approved a bill eliminating the obligation to pay damages for those convicted of excessive self-defense. However, due to the principle of non-retroactivity, the law cannot cancel the compensation already awarded to Roggero.
Lawyers Stefano Marcolini and Sergio Rovani said the jeweler will turn himself in immediately, without naming a prison. A sit-in organized by Futuro Nazionale (National Future ) took place in front of the Supreme Court , where leader Riccardo Corsetto called Roggero "the real victim." Deputy Prime Minister Matteo Salvini announced on Instagram that he will ask President Sergio Mattarella for a pardon, saying that at 72, he doesn't deserve to be in a cell with real criminals.
